| Simon Weaver (Harrogate Town) |
5693 |
| Andy Woodman (Bromley FC) |
1363 |
| Paul Cook (Chesterfield) |
1045 |
| Johnnie Jackson (AFC Wimbledon) |
950 |
| Lee Bell (Crewe Alexandra) |
778 |
| Mat Sadler (Walsall) |
612 |
| Grant McCann (Doncaster Rovers) |
589 |
| Nigel Adkins (Tranmere Rovers) |
468 |
| Graham Alexander (Bradford City) |
411 |
| David Artell (Grimsby Town) |
390 |
| Charlie Adam (Fleetwood Town) |
356 |
| Danny Cowley (Colchester United) |
352 |
| Karl Robinson (Salford City) |
351 |
| Stuart Maynard (Notts County) |
338 |
| Darren Moore (Port Vale) |
312 |
| John Doolan (Accrington Stanley) |
292 |
| Mark Bonner (Gillingham) |
228 |
| Stephen Clemence (Barrow) |
204 |
| Michael Flynn (Cheltenham Town) |
204 |
| Derek Adams (Morecambe) |
201 |
| Nelson Jardim (Newport County) |
158 |
| Mike Williamson (Carlisle United) |
93 |
| Scott Lindsey (MK Dons) |
87 |
| Ian Holloway (Swindon Town) |
57 |
